Skip to main content

Risk Scoring

✅ Feature availability: Vanta built-in risk scoring settings are included with Core Risk Management. Customizing risk scoring settings requires Advanced Risk Management. Refer to Vanta Plans and Pricing for details.

Risk scoring determines how each risk is rated, scored, and grouped into a risk level. Vanta provides built-in risk scoring settings and a default risk rubric. With custom risk scoring, you can change those settings to match how your organization assesses risk, and create register-specific risk rubrics.

⚙️ User permissions: Editors and Admins can manage risk scoring settings. Collaborators assigned as Risk Scenario Owners can reference risk scoring definitions within risk assessments, but can't access risk settings. Learn more: User Permissions by Product Area


Getting started

In a risk assessment, you rate a risk across two dimensions. Your scoring definitions determine the number of risk scores you track, as well as their names and descriptions. Your risk rubric determines how Vanta calculates each score from your ratings and assigns it a risk level. Here are the key metrics:

Metric

How it’s determined

Dimension ratings

You select a rating for each dimension during a risk assessment. Your scoring method determines whether you select each rating directly or rate individual factors that roll up into it.

Risk scores

Vanta calculates each risk score by multiplying your two dimension ratings. Your scoring definitions determine how many risk scores you track for each risk.

Risk levels

Vanta maps each risk score to a risk level based on your risk level groups. Risk levels group and interpret how severe a score is.

💡 Tip: The risk scores you see in reports and snapshots are calculated from your dimension ratings. See examples


Customizing risk scoring

Here’s how the built-in settings in Vanta risk scoring compare with custom risk scoring options:

Setting

Vanta built-in settings

Custom settings

2 scores with customizable names and definitions

2 or 3 scores with customizable names and definitions

3 levels with preset score ranges

2 to 5 levels, with customizable score ranges, names, and descriptions

2 dimensions with fixed names and descriptions, each rated on a 5-point scale

2 dimensions with customizable names, descriptions, and rating scales

Simple scale for each dimension

Simple scale or aggregate factors for each dimension

One default rubric for all risks

One default rubric and register-specific rubrics

⚠️ Note: If you change how risks are calculated, risks you’ve already scored and approved may need to be reassessed, including:

  • Switching between 2 and 3 risk scores

  • Changing your scoring method

  • Editing the range of a rating scale

  • Adding or removing factors

  • Switching your factor roll-up method

Edits to names, descriptions, and labels don’t require you to rescore or reapprove risks.

💡 Tip: You can ask the Vanta Agent to score your risks. It proposes ratings for your approval. Example prompt: “I updated our risk settings. Please propose new ratings for the risks that need rescoring.”


Scoring definitions

Scoring definitions determine which risk scores you track for each risk and what each one means. They apply across all risk rubrics in your workspace and have two parts: a profile that sets whether you track two risk scores or three, and definitions that set the name and description of each risk score.

Here are the built-in names and descriptions Vanta provides out of the box:

Default name

Description

Profile eligibility

Inherent risk

Risk score before considering controls or actions that reduce this risk

This first risk score is available in the three-score profile only

Residual risk

Risk score based on the controls and actions currently in place, and how well they are working

This second risk score is available in both two-score and three-score profiles

Target risk

Risk score expected after all planned treatment actions are complete

This third risk score is available in both two-score and three-score profiles

ℹ️ Note: You might be using our legacy scoring definitions, a two-score profile with the defaults Inherent risk and Residual risk. There’s no change to product behavior, only to the names and definitions of the two risk scores.

To use the new built-in scoring definitions instead, go to your risk settings and ask the Vanta Agent to help. Example prompt: “Please update my risk score names and definitions to the new Vanta built-in settings.”

Updating your scoring profile

Update your profile to change whether you track two risk scores or three.

To update your profile:

  1. Go to Settings.

  2. From the page menu, select Risk and go to the Scoring tab.

  3. In the Scoring definition section, click Edit.

  4. Under Profile, select the option with the number of risk scores you want to track:

    • Select Two-score profile to track risk after controls and after treatment.

    • Select Three-score profile to track risk before controls, after controls, and after treatment.

    • Click Help me choose if you’d like to compare both options with the Vanta Agent.

  5. Click Save—changes apply across all risk rubrics, including register-specific rubrics.
    ​

⚠️ Note: If you switch to a three-score profile, you’ll need to reassess impacted risks to account for the new risk score. If you switch to a two-score profile, the first of the three risk scores is removed from your risks, and your remaining risk scores stay unchanged.

Editing scoring definitions

Edit definitions to change the name and description of each risk score.

To edit definitions:

  1. Go to Settings.

  2. From the page menu, select Risk and go to the Scoring tab.

  3. In the Scoring definition section, click Edit.

  4. Under Definitions, edit the name and description for each risk score.

  5. Click Save—changes apply across all risk rubrics, including register-specific rubrics.


Risk rubric

A risk rubric is made up of dimensions and risk level groups. Dimensions are what you rate a risk on during a risk assessment to calculate risk scores. Risk level groups map each risk score to a risk level.

Every workspace has a default rubric. With custom risk scoring, you can edit the default rubric settings and create register-specific rubrics to use different settings for a single register.

Default rubric

Your default rubric applies to every risk register that doesn’t have its own register-specific rubric.

To edit the default rubric:

  1. Go to Settings.

  2. From the page menu, select Risk and go to the Scoring tab.

  3. Under Default rubric, click Edit.

  4. Edit the risk level groups and dimensions.

  5. Click Save:

    • Select which registers to apply your changes to.

    • Registers you exclude from the update will use their own register-specific rubric going forward.

Rubrics by register

Each risk register uses either the default rubric or its own register-specific rubric. New registers use the default rubric, and you can give a register its own rubric when it needs different scoring criteria.

To edit a register-specific rubric:

  1. Go to Settings.

  2. From the page menu, select Risk and go to the Scoring tab.

  3. Under Rubrics by register, find the register you want to update.

    • The Default badge means the register uses the default rubric.

    • The Register-specific badge means it has its own rubric.

  4. Open a register:

    • Click Edit to create or update a register-specific rubric.

    • Click ••• and select Use default to go back to the default rubric.

  5. Click Save.

Keep these points in mind when using register-specific rubrics:

  • If your registers use different rating scales or risk level groups, you need to filter by register in your risk reports. Charts can’t combine registers that use different risk rubrics into a single view.

  • CSV import and export across all registers are disabled when you use register-specific rubrics. You need to import or export one register at a time.

  • Register-specific rubrics are managed one register at a time. Edits to one register’s rubric don’t apply to any other register. Changes you make to the default rubric apply to the registers you select when updating it.
    ​

💡 Tip: To give a register the same risk rubric settings as another register, ask the Vanta Agent. The registers stay independent, so later edits to one don’t change the other. Example prompt: “Please update [Register A] to use the same risk rubric settings as [Register B].”


Risk level groups

Risk level groups map each risk score to a risk level. Each group is made up of a score range, a name, and a description. When a risk score falls within a score range, the risk gets that risk level. You can customize the number of risk levels and how risk scores map to each one. Changing score ranges can move risks into different risk levels, but it doesn’t change their risk scores.

Here are the three built-in risk levels and score ranges Vanta provides out of the box:

Risk level

Score range

Low

1–4

Med

5–14

High

15–25

💡 Tip: You can choose between two color palettes to change how risk levels are displayed in reports and snapshots. Learn more

Editing score ranges

Score ranges determine where each risk level starts and ends.

To edit score ranges:

  1. Open the risk rubric you want to edit.

  2. Go to the Risk level groups section.

  3. Use the Range slider to determine the ranges:

    • The available range depends on the rating scales in your dimension settings.

    • If a risk score falls exactly on the boundary between two risk levels, it’s grouped into the higher risk level.

  4. Click Save.

Editing risk levels

Edit risk levels to change how many risk levels you use and how each one is described.

To edit risk levels:

  1. Open the risk rubric you want to edit.

  2. Go to the Risk level groups section.

  3. Under Level groups:

    • Use the + and x icons to choose the number of risk levels (from 2–5).

    • Click the ✎ pencil icon to edit the name and description of each level.

  4. Click Save.


Dimensions

Dimensions are what you rate a risk on during a risk assessment. Each dimension is made up of a definition, which is a name and description, and a scoring method. The scoring method determines how the dimension rating is set: you either select it directly, or rate individual factors that roll up into it.

Here are the two built-in dimensions and scoring method Vanta provides out of the box:

Name

Scoring method

Likelihood

Simple scale with a 5-point rating scale

Impact

Simple scale with a 5-point rating scale

Editing dimension definitions

Edit a dimension’s name and description to change how it appears in a risk assessment.

To edit the dimensions:

  1. Open the risk rubric you want to edit.

  2. Scroll to Dimensions.

  3. For each dimension, update the Name and Description.

  4. Click Save.

Simple scale scoring method

With the simple scale scoring method, you select each dimension rating directly from a rating scale during a risk assessment. A rating scale is a set of numbered ratings, and each rating has a name and description.

To use a simple scale:

  1. Open the risk rubric you want to edit.

  2. Under Scoring method for a dimension, select Simple scale.

  3. Set the Scale range to determine the number of ratings to use (from 2–10).

  4. Next to each rating, click the ✎ pencil icon to add a Name and Description to guide consistent scoring.

  5. At the top of the page, review your Risk level groups to make sure the score ranges fit your rating scales.

  6. Click Save.

Aggregate factors scoring method

With the aggregate factors scoring method, you rate individual factors during a risk assessment, and those factor ratings roll up into the dimension rating. Each factor has its own rating scale. Your roll-up method determines how the dimension rating is calculated:

Roll-up method

How dimension rating is calculated

Average

Sum of all factor ratings divided by the total number of factors is used as the dimension rating (can be a decimal value, shown to two decimal places).

Max

Highest factor rating is used as the dimension rating.

Sum

Sum of all factor ratings is used as the dimension rating.

To use aggregate factors:

  1. Open the rubric you’d like to edit.

  2. Under Scoring method, select Aggregate factors.

  3. Next to Roll up with, select Average, Max, or Sum.

  4. Under Add or remove factors, choose the factors for the dimension:

    • Select a factor template to use as a baseline.

    • Type a name to create a factor from scratch.

  5. Under Factor order, drag the factors into the order they should appear on risk details, or use the move buttons.

  6. Scroll down to Factors used in this rubric and edit each factor:

    • Update the Name and Description.

    • Set the Scale range to determine the number of ratings to use (from 2–10).

    • Next to each rating, click the ✎ pencil icon to add a Name and Description to guide consistent scoring.

    • Turn on Allow assessors to mark this factor N/A to allow people to skip the factor during a risk assessment. A factor marked N/A is excluded from the dimension rating calculation.

  7. At the top of the page, review your Risk level groups to make sure the score ranges fit your rating scales.

  8. Click Save.
    ​

ℹ️ Note: Factors aren’t shared across risk rubrics. If you edit a factor in one risk rubric, other risk rubrics don’t change. Registers that use the default rubric share one set of factors, because they use one shared risk rubric.


Example calculations

Risk scores are calculated by multiplying the two dimension ratings, which are Likelihood and Impact by default. Your scoring method determines how each dimension rating is set, either by selecting it directly or by rating factors that roll up into it. Each risk score then falls into a risk level. Risk scores and risk levels are tracked in reports and snapshots.

Example: Simple scale

With a simple scale, you select each dimension rating directly. In this example, both dimensions use a 1–5 scale.

Dimension

Dimension ratings you selected

Likelihood

4

Impact

3

Vanta multiplies the two dimension ratings: 4 × 3 = 12. The risk score is 12.

Example: Aggregate factors

With aggregate factors, you rate each factor, and the factor ratings roll up into the dimension rating. In this example, each dimension has two factors rated on a 1–5 scale, and both dimensions use the Average roll-up method.

Dimension

Factor ratings you selected

Dimension rating calculation

Likelihood

Threat: 3

Vulnerability: 5

(3 + 5) ÷ 2 = 4

Impact

Financial: 2

Operational: 4

(2 + 4) ÷ 2 = 3

Vanta multiplies the two dimension ratings: 4 × 3 = 12. The risk score is 12.